How the NAIC Complaint Index Works
The National Association of Insurance Commissioners collects closed, confirmed complaints that state insurance departments report and publishes them through its free Consumer Insurance Search tool. You can look up a company by name, state and type of insurance, and the results cover the past three years.
1
Find the share of complaints. Divide the company’s complaints for a coverage type by all complaints for that type.
2
Find the share of business. Divide the company’s premium for that coverage type by all premium for that type.
3
Divide the first by the second. The result is the complaint index.
4
Read it against 1.00. At 1.00, complaints match the company’s size. Above 1.00 means more complaints than its size predicts, below means fewer.
Example only:
If a made-up insurer writes 2% of the accident and health premium in a state and draws 4% of the complaints, its index is 2.00, or twice the expected level. If it draws 1% of the complaints, its index is 0.50. These numbers illustrate the math and do not describe any real company.
The NAIC itself notes that an index can move because of shifts across the whole market for that coverage type, not only because of the company. Small insurers can swing far from 1.00 on a handful of complaints.
Complaint-data tip
The NAIC Consumer Insurance Search lists complaints under each insurer’s legal name and NAIC company code, not the brand name. The legal name and code appear on the policy, the certificate or the outline of coverage, and searching that exact entity avoids mixing in a sister company that sells other products.
Russell Noga, Licensed Insurance Agent
Our Table: Ratings and Complaint Data for Six Carriers
Review sites rarely list the regulator data next to the ratings, so we pulled both for six insurers that sell hospital indemnity plans. Complaint figures come from Indiana’s 2025 Health Complaint Index, one of the few state reports that names each insurer with its premium, complaint count and index in one place.
| Carrier |
Insurer we checked |
AM Best financial strength |
Indiana 2025 health complaint index |
| Aflac |
American Family Life Assurance Co. of Columbus |
A+ (Superior), stable, affirmed Oct. 2026 |
2.56 (4 complaints) |
| MetLife |
Metropolitan Life Insurance Co. |
A+ (Superior), stable, affirmed April 2026 |
1.37 (4 complaints) |
| Mutual of Omaha |
Mutual of Omaha and United of Omaha |
A+ (Superior), affirmed April 2026 |
Not listed |
| Wellabe |
Medico and affiliated insurers |
A (Excellent), stable, affirmed June 2026 |
Not listed |
| Guarantee Trust Life |
Guarantee Trust Life Insurance Co. |
A (Excellent), raised from A- in Oct. 2024 |
Not listed |
| ManhattanLife |
Manhattan Insurance Group members |
B++ (Good), raised from B+ in Nov. 2022 |
Not listed |
Our analysis of AM Best rating releases and the Indiana Department of Insurance 2025 Health Complaint Index (complaints per premium dollar, Medicare and Medicaid premium excluded). The Indiana figures cover each insurer’s whole health line in that state, not hospital indemnity alone. Not listed means the insurer did not appear in the table, which leaves out companies with zero complaints. Checked Nov. 2026; confirm current ratings on AM Best before buying.
How to read it
Both indexes above 1.00 rest on four complaints each. That is enough to push the number well past the baseline, which is why one state’s single year should be treated as a prompt to dig deeper, not a verdict.
Aflac is the biggest name in workplace supplemental coverage, so its review volume is high. Our Aflac hospital indemnity page covers how its plans pay, and our Mutual of Omaha hospital indemnity page does the same for an individual-market option.
State Insurance Department Lookups
Your state’s insurance department licenses the insurer, takes complaints and can confirm whether a company may sell in your state. Each state publishes its data a little differently.
How three states report complaints
Indiana
index by premium; insurers under $1 million in premium are not calculated
Kansas
lists top 20 premium writers per line plus any insurer with 10 or more closed complaints
Texas
open data with confirmed complaints and policies in force by line of coverage
Texas measures complaints against policies in force rather than premium, so a Texas figure and an Indiana figure for the same company are not directly comparable. Search your department’s site for complaint index, complaint ratio or company lookup, and check whether a license is active before you apply.