Two Posted Cigna Menus, Plan 1 Against Plan 2
Cigna does not publish one national Hospital Care schedule; each employer picks its amounts. In each cell below, the first figure is Plan 1 and the second is Plan 2.
| Benefit line |
Dartmouth College (HC110988) |
World Wide Technology (HC110724) |
| Hospital admission, regular or ICU |
$1,000 / $2,000, 1 day |
$1,000 / $2,000, 1 day |
| Daily hospital stay |
$100 / $200, up to 31 days |
$100 / $200, up to 30 days |
| ICU |
$200 / $400 a day, up to 31 days |
Extra $1,200 / $2,400 on ICU day 1, then $200 / $400 a day through day 30 |
| Observation, per 24 hours |
$100 / $200 after a 12-hour observation period, 72-hour cap |
$100 / $200 after a 24-hour elimination period, 72-hour cap |
| Chronic condition admission |
$50 / $100 |
$50 / $100 |
| Newborn nursery |
Not listed |
$250 / $500 admission, then $100 / $200 a day up to 30 days |
| Wellness incentive |
Not listed |
$50 / $50, once a year |
| Employee only |
$11.23 / $22.27 monthly |
$4.27 / $8.11 semi-monthly |
| Employee and spouse |
$22.87 / $45.56 monthly |
$10.98 / $20.91 semi-monthly |
| Employee and children |
$18.92 / $37.64 monthly |
$8.54 / $15.92 semi-monthly |
| Employee and family |
$25.98 / $51.80 monthly |
$15.26 / $28.80 semi-monthly |
Sources: Cigna Hospital Care benefit summaries posted by Dartmouth College (group policy HC110988, 2026 Cigna summary, monthly rates) and World Wide Technology, LLC (group policy HC110724, 2023 Cigna form, semi-monthly rates). Neither summary states a plan year. Examples only; both say costs are subject to change, and the group certificate controls. Checked Nov. 2026.
The pattern in both menus
Plan 2 doubles Plan 1 on every dollar line except the $50 wellness incentive. Day limits, frequency rules and exclusions stay the same, so the choice is only about the size of the check.
Plan 2 Costs Twice as Much, or a Little Less
Since Plan 2 pays exactly double, the fair test is whether it costs exactly double. The table converts each rate to a yearly figure and divides Plan 2 by Plan 1. A ratio under 2.00 means the higher level is priced slightly better per benefit dollar.
| Coverage tier |
Dartmouth per year, Plan 1 / Plan 2 |
Ratio |
WWT per year, Plan 1 / Plan 2 |
Ratio |
| Employee only |
$134.76 / $267.24 |
1.98 |
$102.48 / $194.64 |
1.90 |
| Employee and spouse |
$274.44 / $546.72 |
1.99 |
$263.52 / $501.84 |
1.90 |
| Employee and children |
$227.04 / $451.68 |
1.99 |
$204.96 / $382.08 |
1.86 |
| Employee and family |
$311.76 / $621.60 |
1.99 |
$366.24 / $691.20 |
1.89 |
Our math from the two posted summaries: monthly rates x 12, semi-monthly rates x 24. Rounded to the cent; your employer’s rates will differ.
What the ratio tells you:
At World Wide Technology’s rates, Plan 2 is about 5% to 7% cheaper per benefit dollar than Plan 1. At Dartmouth’s, the two are priced almost identically. Plan 1 is not the better value; it is simply less coverage for less money.
What the Extra Premium Buys in Four Example Stays
These examples use the World Wide Technology design, which has the most benefit lines.
1
A one-night stay. Plan 1: $1,000 admission plus $100 for the day, or $1,100. Plan 2: $2,200. Plan 2 adds $1,100.
2
A five-day stay. The federal Healthcare Cost and Utilization Project put the average U.S. inpatient stay at 4.6 days in 2016 (Statistical Brief 246). Rounded up to five days: Plan 1 pays $1,500 and Plan 2 pays $3,000, a $1,500 difference.
3
A four-day ICU stay. Plan 1: $1,000 admission, the $1,200 ICU day-one amount and three more ICU days at $200, or $2,800. Plan 2: $5,600, a $2,800 difference. Dartmouth’s design has no ICU day-one line.
4
A newborn’s three-day nursery stay. Plan 1: $250 nursery admission plus three days at $100, or $550. Plan 2: $1,100. This is separate from the parent’s own delivery admission.
All four are examples and assume the daily benefit pays for each day confined, including the admission day; a certificate may count days differently. When a day qualifies for both a regular stay and ICU, only the larger amount is paid.